The Caribbean, Bermuda, and the Bahamas
| Hotel | Score | Location |
|---|---|---|
| Cap Juluca | 87.88 | Anguilla |
| CuisinArt Resort & Spa | 87.02 | Anguilla |
| Malliouhana Hotel & Spa | 88.86 | Anguilla |
| Jumby Bay | 92.24 | Antigua |
| Playa Linda Beach Resort | 81.27 | Aruba |
| One & Only Ocean Club at Paradise Island | 83.77 | Bahamas |
| Pink Sands | 81.67 | Bahamas |
| Sandy Lane | 84.71 | Barbados |
| The Reefs | 86.45 | Bermuda |
| Ritz-Carlton, Grand Cayman | 85.45 | Cayman Islands |
| Club Med Punta Cana | 81.25 | Dominican Republic |
| Couples Sans Souci | 86.50 | Jamaica |
| Grand Lido Braco Resort & Spa | 84.40 | Jamaica |
| Jamaica Inn | 89.78 | Jamaica |
| Rockhouse Hotel | 81.99 | Jamaica |
| Round Hill Hotel & Villas | 85.21 | Jamaica |
| Royal Plantation, Ocho Rios | 85.28 | Jamaica |
| Four Seasons Resort | 88.10 | Nevis |
| Peter Island Resort | 85.97 | Peter Island |
| Horned Dorset Primavera | 88.54 | Puerto Rico |
| Eden Rock Hotel | 88.70 | St. Bart's |
| Hotel Guanahani & Spa | 85.81 | St. Bart's |
| Hotel Saint-Barth Isle de France | 88.81 | St. Bart's |
| Ladera | 91.34 | St. Lucia |
| Grace Bay Club | 82.83 | Turks and Caicos |
| Parrot Cay | 82.00 | Turks and Caicos |
| Biras Creek | 85.00 | Virgin Gorda |
